Season 1 Episodes
1. Crackin' Cards
Preston and his friends help expose a debit card scam at Jamestown University, but must avoid interfering with the official investigation led by Preston's mother.
2. Elephant in the Room
Preston deals with his new roommate, his best friend Noah; Amanda and Mitch investigate when an elephant tusk is intercepted in the mail.
3. The Long Shot
Preston helps Noah try win a $50,000 scholarship; Preston's mother and her team search for a scam artist posing as a psychic.
4. Final Distraction
Preston and his friends try to manage a cute girl's overbearing nature; Inspector Wainwright and her team track down a scammer who targets the elderly.
5. The Slow and the Furious
Noah and Preston help Veronica practice for her driving test; Amanda tries to enjoy her vacation, but another social security scam pulls her into a case.
6. Semper Phi
Preston and Noah experience fraternity pledging at Jamestown University; a scam targets the relatives of fallen soldiers.
7. The Heart Is a Lonely Scammer
Preston encounters peer pressure when he tries out for the archery team; catfishing criminals steal money from possible suitors.
8. We Take Care of Our Own
Preston reluctantly agrees to tutor the guy who is dating Preston's crush, Veronica; Franklin helps a letter carrier who was attacked on the job.
9. Threatening Letters
Preston's friend Veronica wants to move out of her parents' house and into her own apartment; Jamestown University's president receives threatening letters.
10. Arrivederci Milo's
Preston tries to keep President's Cafe open; letters containing poisonous chemicals are sent to medical professionals.
11. Jersey Blues
When Preston tries to help Noah find a birthday present for his father, they end up buying a phony jersey supposedly worn by Dan Marino.
12. Noah's Story Arc
13. Fast Tracking
Preston is the first freshman to land a spot on the debate team, where he deals with a hard-to-please coach; Amanda and Mitch investigate counterfeit money orders.
14. Storm Chasers
A racing wheelchair is stolen; a con artist targets hurricane victims.
15. 30 Days
The gang helps raise money to cover a schoolmate's tuition after his family falls victim to an investment scam; Amanda's team works to find the criminals responsible.
16. Too Good to Be True
Veronica's co-worker draws suspicion; Amanda and the team investigate an investment company that seems shady.
17. Identity
Preston is concerned for Veronica when her ex-boyfriend comes to town; Amanda's team looks into identity theft crimes.
18. The Imitation Games
In a look back at Season 1, actress Jessica Lundy examines the crime of smuggling illegal ivory into the United States; a counterfeit sports memorabilia scam.
19. The Great Pretenders
A look back at Season 1 features a fake physic using the mail to scam customers and one of Preston's friends dealing with identity theft.
20. Gone Phishing
The inspectors auction their services for charity; Mitch and Amanda look into a cat-phishing scam.
21. Psychic Rabbit
Preston and his friends compete in the university talent show; the team investigates a fake debt collection agency.
22. No Good Deed
Preston is an on-set movie star consultant; Amanda and Mitch investigate a charity scam.
23. Jamaican Lottery
Veronica is apprehensive about singing the national anthem at a Jamestown University basketball game; Amanda and Mitch investigate a fraudulent lottery scheme.
24. More than a Feeling
Preston tries to work up the courage to tell Veronica what he really thinks about her before she leaves for a semester in Italy; Amanda and her team collect evidence against a suspect scamming a local church.
25. Tussles and Threats
After an attack on one of their own, the inspectors track down a criminal sending threatening letters to a university president.
26. The Imposters
The investigation of a criminal pretending to be a military officer and the luring of a potential catphish online are featured in a look back at Season 1.